What Was Hidden Inside

Now Josh stood in my kitchen, looking uncomfortable.
“Emma dropped a pencil between the cushions last night,” he explained. “I turned the couch over and noticed the fabric underneath had been sewn shut by hand.”
“Arthur repaired that thing constantly.”
“That’s what I figured. But one seam looked newer.”
He placed the package on my table.
“Did you know what he was hiding inside?”
I shook my head.
“I opened the wrapping,” Josh admitted. “I read the first few lines before I realized it was private. I’m sorry.”
He pushed the $20 toward me.
“Emma loves the couch, but if you want it back, I’ll bring it over.”
I looked at Arthur’s handwriting.
“Keep the couch, Josh. She needs somewhere to watch her cartoons.”
After he left, I found some scissors.
Inside the wrapping was a thick stack of handwritten pages, held together with rubber bands.
A letter rested on top.
The first thing I saw was a date.
June 14.
Maisie’s birthday.
Our first daughter would have turned 33 that year. But she’d lived for only eight months.
Beneath the date, Arthur had written:
“I couldn’t tell you this while I was alive.”
I sat down.
“Arthur, what have you done?”
The next page had a title.
The Life We Didn’t Get.
Below it was another heading.
Maisie’s Fifth Birthday.
The first chapter described a little girl refusing to wear matching socks.
“Nobody can see them inside my shoes,” Maisie argued.
“They’ll know,” her mother replied.
“Then they shouldn’t be looking.”
I laughed.
Arthur had given her my stubbornness.
In his story, Maisie wanted a chocolate birthday cake. Arthur bought one with raspberries, which she hated.
She refused to eat until he removed every raspberry.
Then I reached a sentence that stopped me.
Monica watched our daughter blow out five candles. For once, she didn’t have to wonder what this birthday might have looked like.
I lowered the pages.
Arthur and I had spent years trying to make peace with the birthdays Maisie never celebrated.
Yet he’d imagined them all.
At eight, she learned to ride a bicycle.
At 12, she wanted to become a veterinarian.
At 16, she brought home a boy Arthur disliked because he called him “buddy.”
I laughed again.
Arthur couldn’t stand that word.
“Oh, Arthur.”
But the farther I read, the more unsettled I became.
He’d imagined an entire life for Maisie.
School dances. Arguments. Holidays. Her first apartment.
Even her wedding.
How long had he been writing this?
And why hadn’t he told me?
I carried the manuscript into our bedroom.
Arthur’s desk stood beside the window. I’d barely opened it since he died.
“All right, mister. Let’s see what else you’ve been keeping.”
The first drawer held Arthur’s old batteries.
In the second, I found three notebooks, one containing 12 years of writing notes.
Maisie learns to swim.
First terrible haircut.
Monica teaches her to drive.
Near the back, Arthur had written:
Hid manuscript in couch. Need courage to show Monica.
Then I found a sentence he’d underlined.
Don’t make her perfect.
Arthur hadn’t imagined a daughter who never argued or made mistakes.
He’d given Maisie a personality.
A life.
I picked up the manuscript and found the wedding chapter.
Maisie stood before a mirror while I fastened her dress.
“Mom, you’re making that face.”
“What face?”
“The one you make when you’re trying not to cry.”
Arthur had noticed that about me.
All those evenings on the couch, he’d been imagining Maisie growing up.
But what about Aurora? Our living daughter had grown up right in front of us.
May you like
I grabbed my keys.
I needed to understand why Arthur had written so much about one daughter while keeping the other outside these pages.