Chapter 8: What Victoria Knew About Daniel

Ruth's paralegal — a quiet, thorough young man named Marcus — came back with the answers three days later.
James was in the kitchen when Marcus called Ruth and Ruth walked in from the living room and set her phone face-up on the kitchen counter between them.
"Daniel Marsh," Ruth said, "is not simply a man Victoria had an affair with."
James waited.
"He is a named party in two prior civil suits.
Both settled out of court, both under non-disclosure.
But the pattern in the filings is consistent." Ruth looked at her notes.
"He has a history of forming relationships with married women.
In both prior cases, a pregnancy was involved.
In both prior cases, the woman's husband initially believed the child was his."
James sat down.
"Victoria knew this?" he asked.
"We believe so.
One of the women involved is a former colleague of Victoria's from six years ago.
They were in contact as recently as last year."
The kitchen was very quiet.
"She knew what he was," James said slowly.
"She knew his history."
"It appears so."
"And she still—"
"Yes."
James pressed both hands flat on the kitchen table.
He stared at the grain of the wood for a long moment.
"What happened to the children in those cases?" he asked.
"The ones where the husband found out."
Ruth was quiet for a moment.
"In one case, the husband remained.
They are still together.
The child was raised as his.
In the second case — the husband left.
Custody became a prolonged legal matter.
It took four years to resolve."
"And Daniel?
What was his involvement with those children?"
"Minimal.
In both cases, once the legal situation became complicated, his engagement decreased significantly."
James looked up.
"So he appears when the situation is managed.
And disappears when it gets difficult."
"That is the pattern."
James thought about the text message on Daniel's phone.
*If he finds out today, I need you to say it was all you.* He thought about Daniel standing at the bottom of the front steps, car keys in hand, having driven here specifically not to do what Victoria had asked.
"Why did he come here?" James asked.
"Honestly.
If this is his pattern — why not just go along with Victoria's story and disappear?"
Ruth looked at him for a moment.
"Marcus found something else."
She turned her phone around.
On the screen was a photograph — a formal one, taken in what looked like a law office.
Two men standing beside each other in suits, shaking hands.
One of them was Daniel Marsh.
The other was a man James did not recognize.
"The man on the right," Ruth said, "is Gordon Marsh.
Daniel's father.
He is a senior partner at a firm that specializes in parental rights litigation." She paused.
"He has been retained, as of this week, to represent Daniel's interests in establishing paternity."
James set the phone down.
"Daniel didn't come here to be honest," James said.
"He came here to establish his presence.
To be seen.
To get on record as cooperative."
"It creates a favorable narrative," Ruth said, "if this goes before a judge."
James stood up.
He walked to the kitchen window and looked out at the backyard — the small swing set he had assembled in March, before the twins were born, on a Sunday afternoon when the air was still cool and everything still felt like it was going exactly as it was supposed to.
"They want those girls," James said.
"Daniel's father is a very effective attorney," Ruth said.
"And biological paternity carries legal weight.
We cannot pretend otherwise."
James turned back from the window.
"What do we do?"
Ruth picked up her phone.
"We move faster than they do.
And we make sure the court understands the full picture — not just the biological facts, but everything.
The affair.
The concealment.
The text messages.
The history of Daniel's prior situations.
Emily's account of what happened in this house." She paused.
"And we document every day you spend with those girls from this point forward.
Every feeding.
Every doctor's appointment.
Every night."
James nodded once.
"There's one more thing," Ruth said.
"Victoria's attorney called this morning."
"Already."
"She's retained Gerald Fitch." Ruth said the name with the kind of careful neutrality that carried its own meaning.
"He's aggressive and he's expensive and he does not negotiate in good faith until he has no other option."
James absorbed that.
"She said there were things I hadn't asked the right questions about yet," James said.
"In the kitchen, before she went upstairs."
"Yes.
We think we now know what she meant." Ruth gathered her papers.
"She intends to argue that you were aware, on some level, that the twins might not be biologically yours — and that you chose not to investigate because you preferred not to know."
The sentence sat in the room like something that had been dropped from a height.
"That's not true," James said.
"I know it isn't," Ruth said.
"But it will need to be disproved.
And that means we need every piece of evidence that shows your complete, genuine belief that those girls were your daughters from the beginning."
She picked up her briefcase.
"Think," she said quietly.
"Every conversation.
Every doctor's visit.
Every decision you made as their father.
We will build the picture piece by piece."
She left.
James stood alone in the kitchen.
On the baby monitor on the counter, he could hear the twins waking from their nap — the small rustling sounds, the soft experimental noises before the real sound came.
He went upstairs before they could cry.
May you like
He was there when their eyes opened.
He was always there.