Chapter 6: What Margaret Remembered

Gerald asked me to meet with Margaret again before the end of the week.
She came to the café on a Thursday afternoon, after the lunch rush.
I poured two coffees and sat across from her at Clark's table.
Neither of us said anything about that for a moment.
"Gerald thinks the key is the estate timeline," I said.
"He told me the same." Margaret wrapped both hands around her mug.
"Our mother passed four years ago.
Clark inherited everything jointly with me — the house, her savings, a small investment account.
We sold the house and divided it.
That was handled properly, through Gerald's office." She looked up.
"Dennis showed up at the memorial.
Said he and our mother had been close.
Said she had promised him something."
"Had she?"
"My mother never mentioned Dennis Pratt in the last five years of her life.
Not once." Margaret's voice was flat.
"He produced a letter.
Handwritten.
Said it was her intention to leave him a portion of the investment account."
"Was it genuine?"
"Gerald had a document examiner look at it.
The ink dating was inconsistent with the paper." She set her mug down.
"But by then, Clark had already given Dennis a payment.
A settlement.
To make him go away."
I stared at her.
"How much?"
"Twelve thousand dollars." She said it quietly, like it still hurt to say.
"Clark never told me until afterward.
He said he just wanted peace.
He said he didn't want a fight." Her jaw tightened.
"That was Clark.
He never wanted anyone to be unhappy, even people who were lying to him."
"Dennis knew that about him."
"Yes," Margaret said.
"He did."
The café door opened.
A regular came in, nodded at me, sat at the counter.
I gave him a moment, then looked back at Margaret.
"The payment," I said.
"Does Gerald know?"
"I told him this morning.
He's pulling the bank records." She looked at me steadily.
"Rachel, Dennis has done this before.
That's what Gerald thinks.
Clark wasn't the first."
Something settled cold and heavy in my stomach.
"Is there a way to prove that?"
"Gerald is looking into two other situations.
Older women.
Neighbors of Dennis from about six years ago." She paused.
"One of them passed away before anything was resolved.
The other one moved away.
Gerald is trying to find her."
I thought about Clark at that table, smiling his wide, genuine smile, asking about Emma's first day at school, sliding his five dollars under the plate.
I thought about him writing those careful letters on those pages.
*I thought about it for a long time and I am sure.*
"He knew Dennis would try something," I said.
"I think so." Margaret's voice was quiet.
"I think that's partly why he prepared so carefully.
Why he had Gerald file everything and witness everything and write everything down." She looked toward the window.
"Clark was not naive, Rachel.
People made that mistake about him his entire life.
He wasn't naive.
He was just kind."
My throat tightened.
"I have the text messages," I said.
"From when he first gave me his number.
And I found photos — Emma and Clark at this table, probably six or seven of them over the months.
And there are the café receipts.
Gerald said the daily timestamp records from our point-of-sale system could establish the pattern of visits."
"That's good."
"Is it enough?"
Margaret looked at me directly.
"I don't know," she said.
"But I'm going to testify.
And Gerald is going to call the document examiner who looked at Dennis's fake letter four years ago." She reached across the table and briefly covered my hand with hers.
"Clark chose you, Rachel.
He chose you carefully and deliberately and he left a paper trail because he knew his own brother — his own mind — better than anyone gave him credit for." She pulled her hand back.
"We are not going to let Dennis Pratt rewrite that."
I nodded.
I didn't trust my voice.
My phone lit up on the table.
A number I didn't know.
I answered.
"Is this Rachel?" A woman's voice.
Older.
Careful.
"Yes."
"My name is Shirley Vance.
I think we need to talk about Dennis Pratt.
Gerald Holt gave me your number." A pause.
"He did the same thing to me.
May you like
Six years ago.
And I kept everything."