Spotlight

Chapter 5: The Wife Before the Wife Before Me

Sandra spoke slowly, the way people do when they've rehearsed something so many times in their head that saying it out loud finally feels almost ordinary.

She had married Derek six years ago.

She was a schoolteacher from a small town in Ohio.

Her grandmother had left her $60,000 — a lifetime of careful saving from a woman who'd worked in a textile mill for forty years.

Sandra had told Derek about it three weeks into dating him, over dinner, because she'd been so happy and hadn't yet learned to be careful with her happiness.

"He proposed four months later," she said.

"I thought it was fast.

My mother thought it was fast.

But he was so — certain.

And nobody had ever been that certain about me before."

"What happened on your wedding day?" I asked, though I already felt the shape of the answer.

"His father came up to me at the reception.

Not Derek.

His father.

He told me that the money my grandmother had left me should really be transferred into a joint account for the sake of 'building a future together.' He made it sound so reasonable.

So grown-up." A pause.

"I did it three weeks later.

Within six months, the account was empty.

Derek said it was investments.

I never saw a single document."

I was pacing Jana's guest room by now, the phone pressed hard to my ear.

"Did you go to the police?"

"I tried.

They told me that money transferred voluntarily between spouses was a civil matter.

Derek had covered his tracks perfectly.

Receipts for things that didn't exist.

A paper trail that looked legitimate if you didn't look too closely." Her voice was steady but thin, the way a surface looks when the wood beneath it has started to warp.

"I had a lawyer.

She did what she could.

In the end, I got very little back and he walked away completely clean."

"Sandra." I sat on the edge of the bed.

"Would you be willing to speak to a lawyer named Greta Foss?

She's building a case.

There are at least three of us now — you, Pauline, and me.

And Pauline has records."

The silence on the other end lasted long enough that I thought the call had dropped.

"Yes," Sandra said finally.

"God, yes.

I have records too.

I've kept everything in a box under my bed for four years because I didn't know what else to do with it and I couldn't make myself throw it away." A shaky exhale.

"I thought I was the only one.

You don't — when something like that happens to you, you feel so stupid.

So ashamed.

Like if you tell someone, they'll ask why you didn't see it coming."

"I almost married him yesterday," I said quietly.

"And I wasn't stupid either."

She made a sound that wasn't quite a laugh but was close.

"No.

We weren't stupid.

He was just very good at what he does."

After I hung up, I sat in the dark for a while with my hands in my lap.

Jana knocked softly and opened the door.

She was carrying a mug and she set it on the nightstand without saying anything about my dress or my shoes or the fact that I'd arrived at her door on what should have been my wedding night with a backpack instead of a suitcase.

"Tea," she said.

"The kind with the bear on the box.

I know you like it."

I looked at the mug.

Then I looked at her.

"He told my parents I had an emotional episode."

Jana sat on the foot of the bed.

"What do you want to do about that?"

"I need to call them.

Tonight.

Before he calls them again."

"Okay." She didn't move.

"Do you want me to stay while you do it?"

I did.

I really did.

"Please."

I called my mother first.

She picked up before the first ring had finished, and the sound of her voice — slightly too bright, covering worry — made my throat close.

"Chloe, sweetheart.

Derek called us earlier.

He said you were upset and—"

"Mom." I kept my voice even.

"I need you to listen to me carefully, and I need you to not say anything to Derek or Brenda until I'm finished.

Can you do that?"

A pause.

"Your father's right here.

Let me put you on speaker."

There was a soft click.

Then my father's voice, quiet and waiting.

I told them everything.

Not all at once.

In pieces.

The rag.

The floor.

The locked room.

Pauline's message.

The unsigned certificate.

Sandra's voice on the phone an hour ago.

By the time I finished, my mother was not crying.

That was the part that surprised me.

She was absolutely silent in the way she gets when she is past the point of tears and into something harder and colder.

My father spoke first.

"The check.

Do you still have it?"

"Yes.

It's in my backpack."

"Don't put it anywhere.

Don't deposit it.

Don't move it." His voice was careful and deliberate.

"We'll talk to our own lawyer on Monday."

"I already have one," I said.

"Her name is Greta Foss.

She's good."

Another silence.

Then my mother: "Are you safe right now?"

"Yes.

I'm at Jana's."

"He doesn't know Jana's address?"

"No."

"Then stay there tonight." A breath.

"Chloe.

I need to ask you something and I need you to answer honestly."

"Okay."

"Did you have any idea?

Before yesterday?"

It was the question I had been carrying since the moment I climbed out of that window.

I turned it over one more time, checking every angle, looking for the place where I should have seen it.

"No," I said.

"And I've been asking myself that for six hours."

My mother made a sound then — small, involuntary, the sound of something releasing.

"Good.

Then stop asking." Her voice steadied.

"You got out.

That's what matters."

Jana was watching me from the foot of the bed when I hung up.

Her face was careful.

"My parents are okay," I said.

"I heard." She reached over and picked up my mug and pressed it back into my hands.

"Drink that before it goes cold."

I wrapped both hands around it.

The warmth moved up through my palms.

"Jana.

He's not going to stop."

She looked at me directly.

"I know."

"Tomorrow's going to be worse before it gets better."

"Probably."

"I just wanted to say it out loud."

"I know." She didn't move.

Didn't offer a solution.

Just sat with me in the dark while I drank my tea, the way a good person does when there's nothing to fix yet and the most important thing is simply not to be alone.

My phone lit up on the nightstand one more time.

Derek.

A text this time.

*"I spoke to your parents.

They're concerned.

Come home and we'll handle this as a family.

This is your last chance to do this the easy way, Chloe."*

I read it once.

Set the phone down face-up so I could see the screen.

I wanted to remember exactly how he phrased that.

*Your last chance to do this the easy way.*

As if there had ever been an easy way.

As if he'd offered one.

I picked up the phone and forwarded the message directly to Greta.

Then I forwarded it to Pauline.

Then I turned off the lamp and lay down on top of the covers in my wedding dress, the backpack on the floor beside me, the cashier's check still folded safely inside.

May you like

I did not sleep for a long time.

But when I finally did, I didn't dream about Derek at all.

Related Stories

Other posts