Spotlight

Chapter 5: Nathan Makes His Move

The access logs came back in thirty-seven minutes.

Patricia set the printed pages in front of me without a word and let me read.

The mentorship repository had been accessed fourteen times using Eli's registered credentials in the six months following his submission.

Eleven of those accesses were Eli himself — I could see the pattern, late evenings, weekends, consistent with a teenager checking whether his work had been reviewed.

The other three accesses were different.

Different device.

Different IP address.

Different time pattern — early mornings, business hours, the kind of schedule that belonged to an adult with a structured workday.

The last of those three accesses was eight months ago.

Preston's submission to this competition had been finalized seven months and three weeks ago.

Patricia tapped the IP address column.

"We can request a location trace through the board's tech compliance partner.

It takes about two hours."

"Request it," I said.

She nodded and reached for the phone.

The door opened before she could dial.

Nathan walked in.

Not a knock.

Not a pause in the doorway.

He walked in like the room belonged to him, with a man in a dark suit one step behind him — narrow briefcase, no lanyard, the particular blankness of expression that meant attorney.

"Dr.

Ellis." Nathan's voice was composed now.

The calculation I had seen in the corridor had settled into something colder and more deliberate.

"I'd like to discuss the preliminary review."

Patricia stood.

"Mr.

Crowe, this is an active compliance proceeding.

Unscheduled entry by a competitor's family member is not permitted."

"I understand that." He didn't look at her.

He looked at me.

"Which is why I've asked our family attorney to accompany me.

We'd like to request a formal pause in the process while we submit independent documentation."

"What documentation?" I asked.

The attorney opened the briefcase and placed a bound folder on the table.

"Developmental notes," Nathan said.

"Draft materials.

Time-stamped files showing Preston's work on this submission going back fourteen months.

We anticipated that a similarity flag was possible given that Preston and the other student were both participants in the same regional mentorship program.

It's entirely reasonable that two talented students working in overlapping subject areas would produce work with surface similarities."

I looked at the folder.

Then I looked at Nathan.

"You anticipated the flag," I said.

"We were prepared for the possibility."

"Fourteen months of draft materials, organized and bound, brought to a compliance review you were notified of less than two hours ago."

Something moved behind his eyes.

"We keep thorough records."

"Nathan." I kept my voice even.

"The access logs for the mentorship repository are sitting on this table.

Three accesses were made to my son's submission file from a device that was not his, at times that were not consistent with his schedule, in the months before Preston's submission was finalized."

The attorney put a hand on Nathan's arm.

Nathan ignored it.

"Your son," he said quietly.

"That's what this is."

"This is what the evidence is," I said.

"I didn't choose what the logs show."

"You have a direct personal interest in the outcome of this review.

Anything you present—"

"I am the compliance chair," I said.

"I don't determine the outcome.

I oversee the process.

The outcome is determined by the full board, and the full board will receive every document on this table, including the access logs, including whatever you've brought, and including the location trace we have just requested."

Nathan's attorney leaned toward him and said something low and quick.

Nathan didn't move.

"Mara." His voice shifted again — something underneath the composure now, something that wanted to sound like reason but felt like warning.

"Think about what you're doing.

This will follow Preston for the rest of his life."

"So will the truth," I said.

He stared at me.

Then he picked up the bound folder from the table.

"We'll be submitting this through the formal channel," the attorney said to Patricia.

"That's the correct process," she replied.

They left.

Patricia waited until the door closed.

"He brought prepared documentation," she said.

"Yes."

"That means he knew before this morning."

"Yes," I said again.

She sat back down and picked up the phone.

"I'm adding this interaction to the official record," she said.

"Unscheduled entry.

Nature of the visit.

Materials presented.

Your response."

"Thank you."

My phone buzzed on the table.

A text from Ethan.

*Eli just came out of his round.

He's asking why you haven't come to find him yet.

What should I tell him?*

I typed back: *Tell him I'll be there in ten minutes.

Tell him he did well.*

I didn't know yet whether that was true.

But I knew my son.

May you like

And I knew what he was capable of.

And I knew, with a certainty that had nothing to do with being his mother, that whatever was in that bound folder Nathan had just walked out with — it was not going to hold.

Related Stories

Other posts